We already knew Madison, Indiana was something special—but now it’s official! Our town just won “Best Small Town in the Midwest” in the USA Today 10Best Readers’ Choice Awards, and we couldn’t be prouder. With its historic charm, river views, tight-knit community, and Main Street magic, Madison is basically the setting of a Hallmark movie—but with real-life heart, hustle, and soul.
To celebrate, we’ve rounded up some of our favorite books that capture small-town vibes, but with diverse, layered characters that reflect the richness of real communities. Think cozy, feel-good reads with depth, perfect for fans of found families, sweet romances, and stories that make you want to pack your bags and move to a tiny town with great pie.
💕 Something to Talk About by Meryl Wilsner
Hollywood-to-small-town vibes + slow-burn sapphic romance
When a former child star and her assistant get caught up in romance rumors, a quiet escape to a small town brings real sparks. Heartwarming, funny, and full of great banter.
🌻 The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna
Coastal cottagecore + magical found family
A solitary witch finds her place among a quirky household in a seaside town—and unexpectedly falls for the grumpy librarian. Cozy fantasy meets queer romance with just the right amount of magic.
🏘 The Charm Offensive by Alison Cochrun
Reality TV meets real-world vulnerability
A queer rom-com about a Bachelor-style dating show gone sideways, this book explores mental health, identity, and unexpected love with a small-town warmth you’ll adore.
🐝 Honey Girl by Morgan Rogers
Big city burnout, small-town self-discovery
When a spontaneous Vegas wedding leads a high-achieving woman to spend a summer in a dreamy PNW home filled with queer creatives and gentle healing, it’s a vibe.
🥧 The Secret, Book & Scone Society by Ellery Adams
Mystery, healing, and scones in a Southern town
This gentle cozy mystery series follows a group of women in Miracle Springs, NC who share stories, books, and secrets. Diverse characters, tender friendship, and small-town magic with depth.
🏠 In the Key of Us by Mariama J. Lockington (MG)
Middle-grade joy with queer Black representation
Two girls connect at a music camp in a small Southern town and discover friendship, feelings, and the courage to be themselves. Beautiful, affirming, and full of heart.
📖 Why We Love These Stories
Small towns aren’t always quiet—and they’re never one-size-fits-all. The best ones are filled with quirks, kindness, and people who show up for each other. These books capture that spirit while centering POC, LGBTQIA+, and other underrepresented voices—because small-town charm belongs to everyone.
📦 Want one of these in your next Lost & Bound Box? Just note it in your preference sheet—we love curating the perfect cozy read.
📚 Have a favorite small-town story with big heart? Tell us on Instagram @lostandboundbooks or comment below!
Leave a comment